Blog - Monday, November 1, 2010 0:02 - 18 Comments

Social Media for Social Lynching? Facebook as a Platform for Xenophobia Following the Announcement of an Azerbaijani Film Festival in Yerevan

by

One of the negative stereotypes about Azerbaijan and Azerbaijanis that I often hear from Armenians is that the ‘majority of Azeris are intolerant, they are full of hate toward Armenians and not ready for cooperation.’ Then there is the mirroring positive stereotype among Armenians about themselves who, unlike the Azeris, are ‘tolerant, open-minded and ready for cooperation.’ Based on some recent events, I have to question the latter notion.

A few days ago, an announcement was posted on the Armenian language section of Facebook that a Yerevan-based NGO, Caucasus Center for Peace-Making Initiatives (CCPR) is planning to hold an Azerbaijani Film Festival in Yerevan on November 2, 2010. Of course, the event is out of the ordinary, and as expected it has already had some backlash, though there is also a small minority of people who are speaking out in support.  Yet I should confess that the extent of the negative reaction and how fierce it has been has caught me by surprise.

First, the negative reaction has been overwhelming and those who have spoken up in favor, at least on the Azeri Film Festival Facebook page, could be counted on one hand. The most disturbing reaction is the way opposition to the event has been voiced. While few raised their concerns in a respectful way, the loudest voices have directed hundreds of insults and curses toward the organizers, potential attendees, Azerbaijani people and culture.

Crossing every line, some have gone further and resorted to threats of physical violence. The trend has not been limited to Facebook and has carried over to the blogosphere as well. Here are some quotes from a post of Live Journal blogger ‘crazy-patriot’:

‘…grab  him [the organizer of the festival] few times in the streets and break his neck; keep him in a basement for few days hungry, he might come to his senses… get him, put into a trunk of a truck, take him to Karabakh and put him into a jail there, let us see how many days he will survive…do this instead of ‘promoting’ his work on Facebook and other sources…are we really a nation that cannot ‘take care’ of such a jerk internally?…’[i] .

‘Crazy-patriot’ is not alone in his/her desire to ‘take care’ of the organizers. The post has been reposted on the Facebook page of the Film festival on Tuesday, October 26 2010 1:01PM and ‘liked.’ Hundreds of other posts have followed suit, threatening not only the organizers, but also the writer Lusine Vayachyan who created the page of the event on Facebook as well as anyone who has supported the idea. The future attendees of the Festival have not only been labeled ‘Azerbaijanis’ (used as a derogatory term) and ‘traitors’ but have also been threatened to be ‘burned alive along with the organizers,’ ‘to be ‘blacklisted’ and taught a lesson’ etc. The Facebook page has also became a place for mass expression of open xenophobia and racism, often in a very proud manner. Someone even signed his post on October 28, 2010 with words ‘…Respectfully, RACIST and NATIONALIST ARAIK,’ written in capital letters.

There have been dissenting voices. One of the most prominent Armenian bloggers, ‘Unzipped,’ published a post called ‘Nationalists gone hysterical in Armenian sector of Facebook over Azeri Film Festival in Yerevan’ on October 26,2010.  A number of people expressed support for the festival on their Facebook pages; few have tried to engage into dialogue with protesters on the very Facebook page that announced the festival, yet they were silenced quickly. Some wrote blog posts on their Facebook profile, often leading to another round of fierce debate in this rather private environment. These conversations, unlike the ones on the official page of the Festival, have overall remained respectful perhaps because they were among Facebook ‘friends’ only.
The local mass media has remained tellingly silent, as there is almost no mention of the event or controversy over it. The only exception is the website Epress.am, an Independent Journalists’ Network that features a number of articles on the topic, including: Azerbaijan Film Festival in Yerevan Sparks Hatred and Xenophobia; Armenian Writer Threatened for Facebook Page on Azerbaijan Film Screenings in Yerevan; No Enemy Nations, Only Regressive Societies and Governments: Ara Nedolyan; and Intolerance Hidden Under Veil of Patriotism is Dangerous: Opinion.

While I consider myself a proponent of reconciliation, I have certain reservations regarding the constructiveness of this event. We lived through decades of anti-Azeri propaganda. I believe it has to be reversed and the two societies have to gradually learn to appreciate each other and each other’s culture if we hope to ever have a normal life. Yet this change has to happen gradually. An Azerbaijani Film Festival in the midst of anti-Azerbaijani propaganda sets the stage for a backlash, not for learning Azerbaijani culture.

Ultimately, however, for me this is not even an Armenian-Azerbaijani issue, but an issue of freedom of expression. Whether any of us agrees with the organizers or not, they should have a right to organize any festival, in any format at any time except if it promotes hatred and violence, and this one clearly does the opposite. Similarly anyone has the right to protest the organization of any festival, but not through the use of violent means (whether it be physical or verbal). In this case, the protests have already crossed this line.

As this post is being written, the organizers and a handful of supporters are planning to move forward with the festival to be held on Nov 2, 2010 at 4:00PM. Those opposed to the Festival are also mobilizing. According to several posts on the same Facebook page there are plans to ‘prevent the festival from happening at all costs,’ and that the attendees and organizers ‘will be taught a lesson’ etc. What will actually happen on Nov 2 remains to be seen.



[i] Translated by the author



18 Comments

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Armen Gakavian
Nov 1, 2010 8:10

Thanks, for writing this, Phil. I agree with you. Such a film festival might not be the wisest way to move towards reconciliation in th midst of so much hostility, but the organisers deserve our support for their courage and humanism.

But I must go further and say that this is not just about freedom of speech, but about the state of our heart – and I imagine you’d agree with me.

Afa Alizada
Nov 1, 2010 23:46

Thanks for sharing, Phil. The same thing (if not worse) would have happened in Azerbaijan, if anyone tried to organize an Armenian Film Festival in Baku. I also think this kind of “shock therapy” is not necessarily productive in trying to enhance cross-cultural dialogue (if that was the purpose). It only feeds into the radical rhetoric. Organizing a joint Armenian-Azerbaijani Film Festival in Tbilisi perhaps would be less explosive and more productive :)

Phil Gamaghelyan
Nov 2, 2010 6:27

Update: as of 2pm on November 4, 2010 – 2 hours before announced opening of the festival – I found out that the event has been postponed until Nov 12. No formal announcement has been made by the organizers and according the the official Facebook page of the Festival it is still scheduled for today.

Phil Gamaghelyan
Nov 3, 2010 4:18

Update: in the afternoon of Nov 2, 2010, the organizer – Georgy Vanyan – posted an update on the Facebook page of the Festival that said he was not the initiator of the invitation (despite his name and profile being listed as the ‘creator’) and that the date and time listed there were not correct.

Armenia’s Click-to-Share Democracy
Nov 3, 2010 14:58

[...] time). For many, the Internet has become the only hope for pursuing justice. (Unfortunately, Facebook is also used for closed-minded purposes by some in [...]

Vahagn
Nov 5, 2010 13:30

I am sure the azerbaijani version would have not get the chance to be same or worse, because nobody would let it happen there!! This is my main concern in all the initiatives like this one, that there is no balance in the efforts of peacemaking! If someone (mostly the western wise experts with all their money and connections) is trying to make peace, they should really work hard to do it in exactly same way in Armenia and in Azerbaijan, no matter how hard it may appear. Or otherwise – do not peacify anybody, let them deal with their own issues! If you come and peacify only one side, and let the others fuel more hatred, what you will achieve at the end is another horrible war, and that war will be, started by those who hate more, I am sure. I myself am not a hater of any country, but I really dislike (softly to say) the professional western-style manipulations (that act as if they are just clumsy blah blah and donno what’s happening) that claim to be “peace-making initiatives”. I hope I am simple enough for you guys to get my point:)

Vahagn
Nov 5, 2010 14:21

do not label anybody guys, if you yourself are not close-minded, you should not see anybody expressing an opinion freely – as a closeminded person. If I dislike a manipulation done by people who either do not know whats happening or they pose if they do not know, it doesnt mean i dont think free enough. It just means i am not happy by one-sided efforts and i want to see the peacemaking in both countries but not only in mine. It is well-known that if a 3rd party tries to “make peace” in only one side of the conflict, there is something wrong with that process. Probably that 3rd party is in favor of the other (or you may have another option??:))

Phil Gamaghelyan
Nov 7, 2010 3:20

Dear Vahagn, thank you very much for your comments and for sharing your views.
Of course, your views and any other views expressed in a manner that you did, can not and should not be called ‘xenophobia’ and a dialogue and also a debate between as well as within each society on any topic is always great.

If you read Armenian, however, you can see that the clear majority of the comments on the mentioned Festival Facebook page are not simply expressing opinion. A big number of comments, posted by dozens of people are resorting to insults and degrading comments expressed in worst possible words toward another ethnic group and its culture, crossing a line of a debate and, unfortunately, engaging into something that is hard to call anything else but racism or xenophobia. Moreover, many people who comment are openly threatening to engage the crowd of protesters to resort to violence in regards to organizers of the Festival, which again, in my book, is called ‘lynching.’

I fully respect everyone’s opinion including those who disagree with me and am all in favor of freedom of speech, except, as I wrote above, if it promotes hatred and violence. Unfortunately a big number of posts on the mentioned page do precisely that.

Phil Gamaghelyan
Nov 9, 2010 5:30

Update: on Nov 9, 2010, Epress announced that the screening of the Films has been moved to Nov 12 4 pm, to a private apartment in Yerevan. You can see the full story at
http://www.epress.am/FNew.aspx?nid=8192

Phil Gamaghelyan
Nov 12, 2010 5:59

Update: as of Nov 12, 2010 the Azerbaijani Film festival was cancelled again. According to media reports undefined ‘pressure’ has been applied on everyone who considered providing venue to the festival and the organizers were not able to find a place for the screenings.

For more information see Tert.am (http://tert.am./en/news/2010/11/12/vanyan/) and Epress (http://www.epress.am/FNew.aspx?nid=8461)

Tamar
Nov 18, 2010 11:58

more details on the cancellation: http://www.eurasianet.org/node/62382

Tamar
Nov 19, 2010 16:09

and the UK ambassador to Armenia expressing the following
http://blogs.fco.gov.uk/roller/lonsdale/entry/a_stopped_film_festival#comment-form

Global Voices in English » Armenia-Azerbaijan: Does culture unite or divide?
Nov 25, 2010 15:40

[...] and also noting the role that social media played in mobilizing online opposition, Caucasus Edition was also concerned. One of the negative stereotypes about Azerbaijan and Azerbaijanis that I often hear from Armenians [...]

Armenia-Azerbaijan: Does culture unite or divide? :: Elites TV
Nov 25, 2010 16:01

[...] and also noting the role that social media played in mobilizing online opposition, Caucasus Edition was also concerned. One of the negative stereotypes about Azerbaijan and Azerbaijanis that I often hear from Armenians [...]

Armenia-Azerbaijan: Does culture unite or divide? @ Current Affairs
Nov 25, 2010 16:06

[...] and also noting the role that social media played in mobilizing online opposition, Caucasus Edition was also concerned. One of the negative stereotypes about Azerbaijan and Azerbaijanis that I often hear from Armenians [...]

Global Voices na srpskom » Jermenija-Azerbejdžan: Da li kultura spaja ili razdvaja?
Nov 28, 2010 14:02

[...] ulogu koju su društveni mediji odigrali u mobilisanju opozicije, “Kavkasko izdanje” je takođe zabrinuto. Jedan od negativnih stereotipa o Azerbejdžanu i Azerbejdžancima koji često čujem od Jermena je [...]

Ерменија-Азербејџан: Дали културата соединува или разединува? · Global Voices
Dec 15, 2010 17:32

[...] во мобилизирањето на онлајн опозиција, Кавказ Едишн исто така беше засегнат. Еден од негативните стереотипи за Азербејџан и [...]

Кавказский Выпуск – Социальная медия для общественного линчевания? Фейсбук как платформа для проявления ксенофобии, последовавшей за о
Oct 1, 2011 0:14

[...] addthis_options = "facebook,twitter,email,more";Опубликовано первоначально на английском в Hоябре 2010 [...]

Leave a Comment

Comment

Subscribe to our Newsletter